Classic Cinnamon Toast Recipe Read More Easy 15 mins 4 servings Directions Toast the bread. Butter with 1 tablespoon sweet cream butter on each slice. Top with 1/2 teaspoon Rodelle Cinnamon Sugar per slice. You might also like Rodelle Vanilla Bean Apple Butter Recipe Easy 720 mins Pumpkin Spiced Coffee Easy 5 mins Vanilla Bean Cinnamon Buns Medium 120 mins Vanilla Brown Sugar Pop Tart Medium 90 mins