Pumpkin Spiced Vanilla Milkshake Read More Easy 5 mins 1 servings Uses: Gourmet Pure Vanilla Extract, Fairtrade Vanilla Extract Directions Add ice and milk to a strong blender, pulse several times to break up ice. Add ice cream and Pumpkin Spice and Vanilla Extract. Blend until combined. If desired, top with whipped cream. Want something a little lighter? Try our Pumpkin Spiced Horchata for a fun twist on the traditional beverage! You might also like Dirty Cream Soda Recipe Easy 65 mins Dutch Oven Pot Roast with Brown Butter Pearl Onions and Creamy Mashed Potatoes Medium 300 mins Crispy Smashed Home Fries Easy 50 mins Vanilla Mint Lemonade Easy 30 mins